What happened to my rankings!?

One of the most asked questions in our site reviews is “What happened to my rankings!?”. Although we have the possibility of using all kinds of great tools to analyze your website, this question remains one of the toughest ones to answer. Google isn’t always clear about why some sites rank better than others. In this article, I’d like to illustrate how we go about found drops in rankings or traffic, by describing a case we once dealt with.

Please note that we don’t offer the website reviews mentioned here anymore. We do offer SEO courses and plugins to help you optimize your website! If you’re interested in more real-life examples of SEO in practice, check out our Ask Yoast Case Studies!

Analyzing the drop

Perhaps something happened to your website at a certain point that caused your rankings to drop or traffic to plummet. Using for instance Google Analytics, you should try to pinpoint the date of the change. The tool we usually use for that, is Searchmetrics.com. Based upon collected data, so not that useful for newer sites, Searchmetrics tells you at what point things changed. Here’s a real life example:


That simply hurts. This website took a hit around May 18, perhaps a bit earlier already. Luckily, they were able to gain back a lot of their traffic, but things haven’t been quite like before.

What caused the drop

What we do in this case, is align the graphs in Searchmetrics with Google’s algorithm updates. Usually we turn to Moz, as their overview is accurate and has some convenient links to articles about that drop.

Panda 4.0 (#26) — May 19, 2014
Google confirmed a major Panda update that likely included both an algorithm update and a data refresh. Officially, about 7.5% of English-language queries were affected. While Matt Cutts said it began rolling out on 5/20, our data strongly suggests it started earlier.

Hm, that sounds about right. Right? There was a Payday Loan update on the 16th as well, so let’s not jump to conclusions. What could have triggered a Panda penalty in this case?
majestic-exampleThe website at hand is packed with news, has built up quite some authority over the years and its link profile looks awesome (see image on the right). In MajesticSEO, which we use alongside Searchmetrics for deeper insights on backlinks, that deep purple color indicates loads of linking domains. One might argue on the trust flow of these sites, but a lot of these circle around 20-30 and that seems alright (there is always room for improvement, right). This  shouldn’t have anything to do with that drop.

Panda is about quality. So we checked a number of things, like content quality, design quality, code quality. All seemed right. At that moment, we were tearing our hair out and drinking heavily, as we just could not figure out what happened.

Ghost banners

Ghost banner exampleJust the other day, I was at Conversion Hotel and an obvious subject was ghost buttons. Don’t use these, they’re scary. The website we were analyzing might have had a penalty because of another bad spirit, being ghost banners. Google is a machine. Google recognizes certain sized elements on your website, that have a link and might perhaps be a banner. Think along the lines of a popular posts section, a list of product images or (and even worse) links to related articles on other websites. If your website is packed with these, Google could quite easily mistake these for banners.

Does this mean changing something like a sidebar would help you get rid of that possible Panda penalty? That isn’t guaranteed. Too many factors we can’t influence might play a part in this. There is no number one ranking guarantee. You have a part in that optimization, and Google has a part in picking up on changes. So give it your very best go. If you need more help or want to learn more, have a look at the (free and paid) courses in Yoast Academy!

Read more: Google Panda 4 and blocking your CSS and JS files »

Yoast training subscription

  • Get all 9 SEO courses to fully optimize your website & content
  • Get new courses for free!
  • Get access to exclusive Premium content
  • Save 60% with this training bundle!
More info

10 Responses to What happened to my rankings!?

  1. online project site
    online project site  • 4 years ago

    I actually trust yoast team, the plugin is perfect, their pages ranks really well on google

  2. Webbege
    Webbege  • 4 years ago

    Hi Michiel,
    Do you have any free trail of your Platinum SEO reviews tool? So that I can analysis the feature before get purchase.

    • Michiel Heijmans

      Not sure what you mean – the Platinum review isn’t a tool, it’s a consultancy product :)

  3. Seo
    Seo  • 4 years ago

    I just want to fallow Yoast. I use yoast wp lugin and trust these all here

  4. Derek
    Derek  • 4 years ago

    Just read the Yoast blog and subscribe to there newsletter for tips.

  5. Kevin
    Kevin  • 4 years ago

    “Well, we have no idea what happened here, but you should give us money anyway.”

    • Michiel Heijmans

      See my response to Milas. It’s not that b/w.

  6. Neo Ni
    Neo Ni  • 4 years ago

    Hi Michael,

    If someone doesn’t wanna buy Platinum SEO Review, is there any other way like free resources or tip? Hope you will reply.

  7. Milas
    Milas  • 4 years ago

    Is it me or you never found out what happened?

    • Michiel Heijmans

      Thanks for asking. We think we did. But when ordering the site review, there is always a second step to take and that is implementing our advice. This post is to show how we approach issues like this and find possible causes. Unfortunately, and I really mean unfortunately, the customer was more attached to his banners and sidebar than he was willing to implement our advice. This review was done a couple of years ago and to this date, the ghost banners are in the website. Rankings haven’t gone up, neither has SEO visibility.

      In a reviiew, we can’t control what the customer does with our advice. We do check back every now and then to see what has been done and how that affected visibility. We have a couple of those cases on our website as well. But as this was a challenging one, with an odd outcome, I wanted to use this example to illustrate what we deal with sometimes.

      Hope that clarifies things, but I do understand it feels like a book without a proper ending. It feels a bit like that for us as well!