Is AI content helping or hurting your website?

New AI content tools are popping up left and right. These tools can help you write a social post, or a whole blog post, answer any question, or even create a brand-new image! This is great and helpful when you only have a little time or need more inspiration. But the big question is, are AI tools actually helping us? Should we be using them to create our content? This blog post will discuss AI content and why we should be mindful of how we use it.

AI-generated content is skyrocketing

AI, or Artificial Intelligence, refers to systems that perform tasks that typically require human intelligence, such as perception, learning, reasoning, problem-solving, and decision-making. And right now, there’s an explosion of AI tools in all shapes and sizes.

The widespread adoption of AI-powered content generators makes it easier than ever to produce content quickly at scale. With just a few clicks, anyone can generate a half-hearted, generic article that a person must edit to fit the tone of their business and make it factual.

It’s easy to get swept up in all the excitement and generate lots of content using these new, shiny tools. There is, however, something we can’t and shouldn’t ignore when using these AIs. It might not surprise you that using an AI tool to create your content results in similar content to others. For one, this isn’t great for your SEO.

It also results in a much bigger issue that affects all of us. This content often isn’t diverse and inclusive at all. It’s created by AIs that were trained with biased content. And this content is often written by the same type of person. Let’s dive into this and find out what can be done!

Using AI tools will create an echo-chamber

One of the main concerns with AI-generated content is the lack of originality and authenticity. While algorithms can mimic the style and tone of existing content, they can’t replace the creativity and originality of real people.

AI-generated content often lacks nuance, depth, and originality, which can harm the credibility and reputation of a brand. Moreover, using AI-generated content can perpetuate stereotypes, bias, and exclusionary practices, as algorithms tend to replicate existing patterns and preferences.

Because AI content tools make it so easy to create content, it’s now easier than ever to produce the same content as everyone else. And if everyone uses the same AI to create content, no one is creating new content. We will, in effect, create an echo chamber with no new thoughts or ideas coming in. This leads to a narrow and non-inclusive view of the world.

François Chollet had a delightful tweet about his thoughts on AI content:

Related to this, Maggie Harrison at Futurism wrote an interesting article about ChatGPT essentially being an automated mansplaining machine. Having just this one, far from inclusive, point of view of the world is hurtful to society in so many ways. It doesn’t account for the vast diversity of people and points of view in our world. Nor does it champion groups of people that have often been neglected and marginalized in the past.

AI training sets have a bias

The Large Language Models (LLMs) that power the likes of Google Gemini, Microsoft’s Bing assistant, and OpenAI’s ChatGPT are trained on content from today’s internet. And while most people would like to believe that the internet is diverse and inclusive, it has some very questionable corners.

We should try to strive for a world that’s much more inclusive than it is today. Using public forums on the internet to train your AIs may not be the best idea. In recent years this has lead to AIs becoming racist and biased.

A few examples

Using the internet of today to train AIs has multiple inclusion problems. This means that the AIs themselves become racist, sexist, or ableist because the content they are being trained on is racist, sexist, or ableist. Let’s look at a couple of examples.

Amazon’s AI hiring debacle

Take, for example, Amazon’s hiring AI. They developed this tool as the “holy grail” of hiring to help them find the right people for the job. Amazon used ten years’ worth of mostly male resumes to train the AI. Of course, this is a reflection of the tech industry overall, but it also means that the tool became sexist.

They may not have intended to create a sexist AI, but because the data it had been fed was skewed towards more male hires, it thought it was doing the right thing. AI will always be biased if the data they are using to train is biased.

Image creation can also be problematic

Another example of AI’s going racist is AI image creation. If you want to generate an image of a romantic couple holding hands, it’s not uncommon to see that all the generators give back predominately white people. In July 2021, Dall-E 2 updated its tool to “more accurately reflect the diversity of the world’s population.” Unfortunately, it still produces photos that are non-diverse. It would only show people of color when you added the word “poor” to the prompt.

This isn’t just limited to people of color; the LGBTQI+ community also fell prey to these non-inclusive images. Of course, the tools can make adjustments to their systems. We still have a long way to go to reflect the world that we are in. As Zoe Larkin (Levity) writes in the blog post on AI bias: “Unfortunately, AI is not safe from the tendencies of human prejudice. It can assist humans in making more impartial decisions, but only if we work diligently to ensure fairness in AI systems.”

Don’t forget about the human edit

To some extent, it’s acceptable to use AI tools as shortcuts. Today, however, content creators use them without considering the data that fed the AIs. This leads to the reinforcement and expansion of echo chambers and contributes to the creation of similar content and the production of racist and non-inclusive/diverse images.

As a result, content creators need to be more aware of the data and algorithms used by AI tools to ensure that their content is authentic, diverse, and inclusive and does not perpetuate stereotypes or exclusionary practices.

A lot of online content is not representative

Amazon’s hiring tool and Dall-E 2 are a few examples of AI content generators going rogue. And it is not strange that AI content tools are going the same way because the internet is filled with content written by English-speaking mediocre white cis men.

For example, a study by Oxford University’s Internet Institute found that (mostly male) editors in the western part of the world made most of the contributions to Wikipedia, creating a skewed worldview.

Even if this is a part of your target audience, it is not the only audience. People from all backgrounds with all kinds of experiences currently make up just a small percentage of voices heard.

If we want to break the cycle of this continuous repeating of the same content, we need to improve at writing and creating more inclusive content. That way, we can train the AIs of the future on a more inclusive and diverse internet. 

Make today’s content better for the future

Try not to be that person from the meeting who repeats what others say. Produce content in your voice and make it accessible to the broadest possible audience. All of this makes for a better internet for everyone.

Communicate appropriately with the audience that you are trying to reach. When you’re writing inclusively, you, my friend, are helping to create content that will make the internet of the future a better place.

Be aware of your own bias

It’s not only AIs that have this bias; we all have an unconscious bias that we are trying to unlearn and evolve. That’s what got us here in the first place. We all need to do better to write more inclusive content. Only by taking the time to write inclusive content will we shape today’s internet. This, in turn, means that we can train the AI tools of the future on more inclusive and less derogatory language.

That’s a big responsibility, we know. And this is not something that will change overnight; it will take time. We’ll undoubtedly get it wrong. But, by making an effort now to create diverse and inclusive content, we’ll start the ball rolling to a better internet.

So, what can we do?

You can use AI tools as part of your content creation process — at Yoast, we even have an online training course helping you use AI for SEO and AI features in Yoast SEO. However, you must edit it manually before hitting publish. Be critical of the content that rolls out of the AI tool. Make sure to do a fact-check. And make the much-needed adjustments. You shouldn’t just adjust the tone of voice in your content but also check it for diversity and inclusivity. You should pinpoint any problematic content. Improve it to a point where anyone can relate to it and you’re comfortable with it.

How to make your content more inclusive

It can be hard to know where to start. That’s where tools can help get you on the path to a more inclusive and diverse internet. For example, our inclusive language analysis in Yoast SEO. This new analysis helps you to spot when you may have unconsciously used a term that is not inclusive or is, in fact, racist, sexist or ableist.

Much like our readability analysis, it looks through your text for words from our database that are racist, sexist, non-inclusive or derogatory. It will help you become aware of those non-inclusive words and phrases. You’ll get feedback and proper alternatives that can improve your content to ensure that site visitors feel spoken to. With just a few small steps in the right direction, we can all hopefully make the world and the web a more inclusive and diverse place for future generations. And for future AIs.

Coming up next!

10 Responses to Is AI content helping or hurting your website?

  1. titancommandllc
    titancommandllc  • 1 year ago

    AI-powered content generators may seem like a great solution for producing content at scale, but it’s important to remember that they’re not a substitute for human creativity and insight. While they can help speed up the process of content creation, they cannot replace the value of original, thoughtful content that resonates with readers. As we embrace new AI technologies, we should continue to prioritize authenticity and creativity in our content to create a meaningful impact on our audience and the wider community.

    • Sam Alderson

      Hi, Thanks for your comment.

      I very much agree. While they are helpful as a jumping off point, it is still far too early to be creating 100% of your content using these tools. They can be a guide or help you if you’re in a rut, but, we need to keep in mind the data sets that these are trained on. They will not be as authentic or trusting as you yourself writing the content. I think that the next couple of months will be fascinating AI wise.

  2. Poulomi Basu
    Poulomi Basu  • 1 year ago

    If you have content written purely by AI, why would anyone look for your site? They can just go to ChatGPT.
    It is only when you bring in EEAT, your expertise, experience, and viewpoint, that you have something genuine to offer.

    • Sam Alderson

      Could not agree more! It’s your life experiences and opinions that bring people to your site.

  3. Tom Tyler
    Tom Tyler  • 1 year ago

    ” We will, in effect, create an echo chamber with no new thoughts or ideas coming in. This leads to a narrow and non-inclusive view of the world.” <—- A Politically Correct echo chamber is precisely what the "diversity police" are attempting to produce. It appears from this article that Google is enforcing this contrived Orwellian "Diversity" Newspeak via its algorithms, and if this is true Google should be both sued and investigated by Congress for it. I'm going to contact the House committee currently investigating Google and Facebook for election interference and censorship about this SEO-censorship issue.

    • Sam Alderson

      Hi Tom, thank you for your comment. I think you may have misunderstood what I have said here.

      If there is only one point of view out in the world, then that is, in fact, an absolutist/Orwellian way of life. Where no other voices or points of view matter. We are aiming to help those that have no voice be heard, represented and have the ability to rank in the search engines, just as much as those that would rather they stay silent. Our goal with this feature is to ensure that there is a fair representation and diversity of opinions in the world so that healthy discussions can happen and that we have a free and open society.

  4. Brooke
    Brooke  • 1 year ago

    I wrote a blog post with ChatGPT, published it last Friday, and the next day, it was ranking on page 1 for the keyword I wrote it for. I think that’s a record for our content. I say ‘I’ wrote it, because I took a lot of time with ChatGPT ensuring it was written with a unique voice and for the right audience. I had to add a few segue paragraphs and it took me as long to publish as a regular blog post. But I will definitely try it a few more times to see how well it does across the board. This has great potential to fill in gaps while my thought leaders are too busy to write, or we’re missing a valuable keyword.

    • Cindy Paul
      Cindy Paul  • 1 year ago

      That’s amazing news! Thank you for your comment. We agree that it’s good practice to go over an AI-generated text if you want to create original content. As long as people are aware that AI tools have their flaws, they can be very helpful indeed!

  5. Armae
    Armae  • 1 year ago

    Such a great article, thank you for sharing this kind of blog.

    • Camille Cunningham
      Camille Cunningham  • 1 year ago

      Thank you! And you are very welcome :)