Ask Yoast: division on seperate domain

Ask Yoast
Give a division a separate domain?

Ask Yoast: Give a division a separate domain?

May 01st, 2017 – 8 Comments

A website of a larger company often represents multiple divisions. If one division outgrows the others, or if expectations for one division are very high, the need for a separate website or domain may arise. What’s best to do for SEO in such a case? Set up a new domain for that division? Or build it on a sub-domain? In this Ask Yoast, we help you determine the best solution in case a division wants its own website.

Brooke Brown of smartbridge.com emailed us with this question:

“One division of our company is getting more presence, so they want to build that division its own website. What’s the best option?

1. Build it on a new domain like smartbridgemobility.com;
2. Build it on a totally separate domain;
3. Build it on a sub-domain like mobility.smartbridge.com.”

Check out the video or read the answer below!

Become a technical SEO expert with our Technical SEO 1 training! »

Technical SEO 1 training$ 199 - Buy now » Info

Division on separate domain

In the video, we help you decide what’s best for SEO if you want to give a division a separate website:

“Well Brooke, first of all I consider myself pretty good at branding and if your brand “Smartbridge” is strong, I would consider doing something much simpler. I would make it smartbridge.com/mobility. Give it its own look and feel, but keep it on one domain.

If you don’t want to do that, but you want to separate the two, then I would give it an entire brand for itself. Because that probably is best in the long run to sell or whatever you want to do with it. I’m not a big fan of sub-domains because they lead, or can lead, to all sorts of technical issues. And they’re a bit of nothing really. It’s not its own brand, it’s far too attached to your main domain.

So I would probably choose a sub-folder and if you can’t do that I would choose a completely different brand. Good luck!”

Ask Yoast

In the series Ask Yoast we answer SEO questions from followers. Need some advice about SEO? Let us help you out! Send your question to ask@yoast.com.

Read more: ‘Domain names and their influence on SEO’ »


8 Responses to Ask Yoast: Give a division a separate domain?

  1. Holiday
    By Holiday on 7 May, 2017

    I don’t believe in sub-domains and i think if e use the main domain for our business, that will be a smarter decision then building a sub-domain and then again create content on that from scratch.

  2. Matt LaClear
    By Matt LaClear on 4 May, 2017

    As a rule, I usually do not take on client’s that use multiple subdomains. It’s not that their sites won’t rank, it just gets too complicated for me to figure out in my old age. Chess is hard enough to play; I’ll leave 3D chess to people with bigger brains than my own.

  3. Pattipie
    By Pattipie on 2 May, 2017

    Great arguments! Thank you for this helpful informations!

  4. Lrers
    By Lrers on 2 May, 2017

    It is a very great post and thanks for sharing with us

  5. Christian Janfils
    By Christian Janfils on 2 May, 2017

    Hi gentlemen,

    next to the interesting comments already mentioned (SEO juice & anteriority) I would add the viewpoint of the end customer. If the end customers of one division are not prospects of the other division or, with other words, if those two divisions address radically different customers, there is no reason to propose on the same website (and domain name) products or services for both prospects categories. Especially if one division really outperforms the other.
    As a customer I am not really interested to see products I would never buy, next to products I’m looking for.
    As Google is very strong on semantics, they know exactly what the site is about and sticking to one semantical area, with great content, will be a strong point for SEO compared to a website where content is diluted on different semantical areas.

    And thanks to Yoast for great articles and content !

    Christian

    • Willemien Hallebeek
      By Willemien Hallebeek on 3 May, 2017

      Hi Christian, Thanks for your useful addition!

  6. Tauseef Alam
    By Tauseef Alam on 1 May, 2017

    Great advice.
    Sub-Folder is a way to go. I have personally tested it and it works like a charm when it comes to SEO. The SEO juice of the domain passes through it properly whereas this is not the case with sub-domain.

  7. Erik
    By Erik on 1 May, 2017

    I would like to add, that a new domain will start from the bottom with SEO. No links to this domain (linkbuilding), no history.. so to build a new brand from a SEO perspective could lead to extra efford to make it as strong as your main domain.


Check out our must read articles about Technical SEO